Pet Custody Battles – More Common Than One Might Think

Imagine spending your life savings on legal expenses to regain possession of a pet after a breakup. Well, that is exactly what some are prepared to do to maintain possession or custody over the family pet. Though this may seem extreme to some. It is not for dedicated pet owners who view the pet as a family member.

Pet custody battles may become more common as the underlying circumstances are becoming much more common as pet ownership increases. According to the 2011-2012 National Pet Owners Survey, 62% of the households in the United States own a pet.

Because these companion animals are often considered members of the family, deciding who their ultimate owner should be after a breakup or divorce can be quite contentious just as high conflict child custody battles often become.

While the public‘s view of pets has evolved beyond mere property interests, the law continues to treat animals as exactly that–no different than furniture, vehicles, or other innate objects. In the event of a breakup, the legal owner of the pet can rightfully retain possession and the other party is left with little recourse. Similarly, during a divorce, the court does not hold custody proceedings or discuss visitation for the couple‘s pets. Instead, pets are addressed in the property settlement.

As a community property state, New Mexico distributes a couple‘s marital assets equally between the two parties. While the distribution of physical property is generally straightforward, allocation of a pet can be very difficult because its value to the parties is much more than monetary, yet the “best interest” standard applied to child custody does not necessarily apply to pets.

Unless, it is clear that one party owned the pet prior to the marriage, the question over who keeps the pet can become very contentious. Unfortunately, divorces are inherently antagonistic, and a dispute over a beloved pet can act as a conduit by which all disagreement between the parties is funneled.

Recognizing the need for a more holistic approach to these difficult questions, some courts are beginning to decide pet-related issues based on principles utilized in child custody proceedings. Although still uncommon, these courts ignore the long-standing distinction and delve into largely subjective issues–asking who the primary caregiver is, who can best meet the animal‘s needs, who has a stronger emotional bond, etc. However, such an approach is certainly not the standard and parties to a divorce or separation should not expect all courts to devote the same time and attention to deciding which party keeps a pet as they do devote to determining child custody issues.

Once entangled in a divorce or even a breakup, deciding who gets possession of your pets will become much more complicated and emotionally charged. In order to avoid added stress, these issues should be discussed and addressed well in advance. Whether you are considering buying a pet with your significant other or want to include pet ownership terms in your prenuptial agreement, consulting an experienced family law attorney can help you explore your options. In the event that a dispute arises, a legal professional can explain the best strategies to ensure your interest in your pet are protected to the degree possible throughout the break-up.


Related Reading:
Breaking Up In New Mexico May Be Harder Than Getting a Divorce
The Hight Cost of Conflict in Divorce

Collins & Collins, P.C.
Albuquerque Attorneys


(505) 242-5958